How to Stop Overthinking Relationships (Even After Being Cheated On)

You’re overthinking your relationship again, aren’t you? Overanalysing every text, every pause in conversation, every time they take longer than 30 seconds to reply. You’re convinced they must be plotting your emotional demise. Maybe they’re cheating. Maybe they’re tired of you. Maybe they’re currently drafting an escape plan. Or – and hear me out – maybe they’re just making a bloody sandwich.

Knowing how to stop overthinking relationships is key to keeping your sanity, because let’s face it—overthinking is like checking your oven 12 times before leaving the house. Annoying, unnecessary, and a symptom of deeper anxiety you refuse to acknowledge. So, let’s sort this out before you drive yourself (and your partner) absolutely mental.

Why Do We Overthink? (And How to Stop Overthinking Relationships)

First off, why are you like this?

Blame your brain. It loves catastrophising, especially if you’ve been burned before. It takes relationship anxiety and turns it into a gripping psychological thriller starring you, an unsuspecting partner, and a host of made-up betrayals.

The problem? Overreacting doesn’t make you more prepared; it just makes you unbearable to date. There’s a difference between intuition and paranoia. If you think, Am I overreacting?, there’s a solid chance that, yes, you are. But let’s break it down properly before you start accusing your partner of a full-blown affair just because they liked someone’s Instagram post from 2017.

The Overthinker’s Survival Guide – 5 Steps to Stop the Spiral

1. Stop Asking ‘Am I Overreacting?’ – Here’s Your Answer

If you have to Google “Am I overreacting in my relationship?” regularly, congratulations – you already know the answer. Sometimes, what looks like overreacting is just past trauma screaming at you. The trick is to fact-check your fears before turning your partner into the villain in your mental drama.

Do this:

• Write down the thought that’s stressing you out.

• Ask: Is there any evidence? (No, their ‘last seen’ time on WhatsApp doesn’t count.)

• Ask: If my best mate told me this, would I tell them they were being ridiculous?

• Act accordingly. (Spoiler: You probably need to chill.)

2. Call Out the ‘What If’ Monster in Your Head

Overthinkers live in a world of hypotheticals, not reality. What if they don’t love me? What if they cheat? What if they wake up tomorrow and realise I’m actually an intolerable goblin?

Listen, mate. Overthinking doesn’t prevent heartbreak – it causes it.

Your partner shouldn’t have to pass an MI5-level interrogation every time they leave the house. If you find yourself stalking their social media with the enthusiasm of a tabloid journalist, it’s time to re-evaluate your priorities.

3. Rewire Your Brain – Less Analysis, More Living

Your overthinking stems from the belief that if you analyse something enough, you can control the outcome. You can’t. Relationships are supposed to flow, not feel like a never-ending strategy meeting.

Try this instead:

• Focus on facts, not feelings. A delayed text does not mean they’re cheating.

• Get a hobby that isn’t them. Seriously, get a life. Join a gym. Take up knitting. Something.

• Stop overanalysing texts. ‘K’ is not a death sentence.

4. Give Your Relationship a Fair Chance

Not every relationship is doomed. But if you treat your partner like they’re guilty until proven innocent, don’t be shocked when they start looking for the exit.

Ask yourself:

• Am I making assumptions based on my past, not their actions?

• Would I date me if I was this paranoid all the time?

If your trust issues are the problem, that’s your job to fix, not theirs.

5. When to Get Professional Help (No Shame in That Game)

If your past relationships were a mess, and you now trust people about as much as you trust British weather forecasts, therapy might be your best mate. A professional can help you untangle your emotional baggage before you ruin a perfectly good relationship.

How to Stop Overthinking After Being Cheated On

Ah, the fun one. You got cheated on, and now your brain is running 24/7 betrayal simulations.

First off, I get it. Trusting again after betrayal is like going back to a dodgy kebab shop after food poisoning. You’re suspicious. You feel sick just thinking about it. And you’re pretty sure it’ll end in disaster.

But here’s the thing: Your new partner is not your ex.

How to Move On Without Losing Your Mind:

• Give yourself permission to heal. You’re not weak for struggling.

• Recognise the difference between caution and paranoia.

• Don’t punish the next person for what the last one did. You’re better than that.

• Set boundaries, not unrealistic tests. Trust takes time.

If you genuinely can’t move forward, be honest with yourself. Maybe you’re not ready for a new relationship yet. And that’s okay too.

Final Thoughts – Overthinking Is the Problem, Not the Solution

Look, mate. You’re not “too much.” But if you really want to know how to stop overthinking relationships, start by trusting yourself first.

The best relationships aren’t built on anxiety, overanalysis, or the belief that you need to be in control at all times. They’re built on trust, mutual respect, and the ability to enjoy each other’s company without an existential crisis every five minutes.

So breathe. Put your phone down. Stop planning for a disaster that isn’t happening. And enjoy your bloody relationship.

---

Get the book!

Enjoying the blog? Why not grab a copy of the book that ties it all together, 127 Reasons Why You Are An Idiot! Chock full of 127 hilarious, sweary, sarcastic, hard-hitting rants about everyday things that everyday idiots do, with quasi-serious, tongue-in-cheek exercises to help idiots be less idiotic.